Resignation statement of the independent members of the JAG Art Gallery Committee
Â
October 16 2026
​
We write as the four independent, non-governmental members of the Art Gallery Committee of the Johannesburg Art Gallery (JAG). We place on record that we have resigned from this Committee.
We write as the four independent, non-governmental members of the Art Gallery Committee of the Johannesburg Art Gallery (JAG). We place on record that we have resigned from this Committee. We remain committed to the Gallery, its staff, its publics and its potential future - and it is this very commitment that requires that we step down, in the hope that our doing so will help open a way past the present impasse, and that a costly and entirely unnecessary legal battle can be replaced with a process of rethinking and repair.Â
​
We also do so in order to be in a position to speak more freely, and plainly. In what follows, we set out our reasons for resigning, and share information about the wider context for that decision.
​
The Gallery faces a formidable set of challenges: a building in disrepair, one of the most significant public collections of art on the continent housed in conditions that compromise its physical integrity, an institution without the capacity or the resources it requires, and with no clear picture of what it should become. These challenges are real and they are urgent. They are also surmountable.
​
Instead of addressing these issues, we have been drawn into a fight not of our making, and with no end in sight. For several years the City of Johannesburg and the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery, together with the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation, have been embroiled in a dispute about who has authority over the institution, the shape of the remedial measures that should be taken, by whom, and with what resources. This conflict has been played out through legal letters, public campaigns, unsubstantiated allegations and rumour mongering, and now an application to the High Court against the City from the Friends which seeks, among other things, our removal. The Friends ask the Court to instruct the Mayor and two as yet unnamed officials to appoint four independent members within thirty days, behind closed doors, with no criteria, nominations, public input or required expertise. It is emblematic of the misdirection of public attention and effort that has characterised this entire matter.
​
In our view both parties have lost sight of what would best serve this institution. The building has not been repaired. The City has not allocated budget for the completion of the temporary relocation of the collection and made it unnecessarily difficult for external partners to contribute resources to the project; all the while incurring significant legal costs in response to the legal threats of the Friends and their lawyers. The Friends have facilitated inflammatory and misleading arguments in the public sphere that have focused collective energies on issues that do not currently solve the problems. The conflict has made the project a difficult one for the corporate and private supporters the Gallery needs, at precisely the moment when external resources have become indispensable.Â
​
At every turn we have argued for a cooperative framework within which these challenges could actually be met, managed and mediated by neutral parties. We articulated this position to the Office of the Mayor in December 2024, and again in July 2025, when we suspended our participation in the Committee altogether and set out the conditions on which we would return. We have pressed the City on its own conduct, and we have rejected the litigiously framed approach taken by the Friends of the JAG, which we view as being wholly counter-productive. That correspondence is now public, and we invite anyone interested to read it. We reject both the entire premise of the legal proceedings launched by the Friends of the JAG and the Heritage Foundation, as well as the account of our conduct narrated there; the record contradicts it.
​
We no longer believe that we can make meaningful progress from inside this structure. Nor are we any longer willing to serve as collateral on the sidelines of a power struggle that we have been unable to mediate and whose consequences we have been unable to mitigate. We therefore step outside it, where we believe we have a better prospect of being useful to the institution.
​
We do so with our commitment to this institution intact, and with gratitude to the Chief Curator and the staff of the Gallery, who have held it and themselves together in conditions no professional should be asked to work in. This is the moment for the antagonists to bring their mandates, partners and resources together in the best interest of addressing the immediate urgencies of JAG’s situation.
​
In this new and fully external capacity, we will be communicating with the Board of the Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery and the Johannesburg Heritage Foundation and the Office of the Executive Mayor, setting out what we believe should now happen, which we will also share more broadly. We have also published the documents on which this statement rests, together with some context and answers to the questions we expect to be asked.
​
The independent members of the Art Gallery Committee (the term of office of each member is indicated in brackets):
Pfunzo Sidogi (since 2022)
Molemo Moiloa (since 2022)
Nontobeko Ntombela (since 2018)
Joseph Gaylard (since 2014)